Keltner Channel VS Bollinger Bands® Which One Is Better?

This is backed by the fact that once the price starts breaking out of the bands, it would mean a relaxation of the squeeze and the possibility of high market volatility and price movement in the future. Bollinger Bands® are most commonly used as a trend-following indicator. When the price stays close to the outer bands, it signals mt4 on catalina a strong trending market. Envelope channel has evolved into a generic term for technical indicators used to create price channels with lower and upper bands. Although Bollinger Bands® are more widely known, Donchian channels, Keltner channels, and STARC bands have proved to offer comparably profitable opportunities.

bollinger bands vs keltner channels

After this initial break, the stock met resistance near the 20-day EMA from mid-May until early August. The inability to even come close to the upper channel line showed strong downside pressure. This indicates that it is a good time to sell an option as the volatility is high. Middle LineThe middle line of the Keltner Channel Indicator calculates andrepresents the exponential moving average , over the selected period, for the price of an asset. Keltner Channels use ATR to calculate the upper and lower lines. The general concept is that the farther the closing price is from the average closing price, the more volatile a market is deemed to be, and vice versa.

Thank you Rayner, that was a very informative article on how to use the Keltner Channel. I’m fairly new at this and still paper trading, trying to get my sea legs. With that said, is this tool applicable to stock and option trading? If it is, I will incorporate it into my chart analysis.I will definitely keep you posted on my progress and hopefully that input can assist you and your community. The volatility of the market moves in cycles, from a period of low volatility to high volatility and vice versa.

Make your money work for you!

We can open a long or short position on Bitcoin and then close the trade when the price hits the middle band. It doesn’t matter how far off the price is from the middle line, as long as the price is going in the correct direction and reaches the middle band. The indicator was reformed in the 80’s by Linda Bradford Raschke, a Californian-based commodities trader. quantitative trading systems In the original version, the upper and lower envelopes were based on the Simple Moving Average and in the newer version they are calculated using the Exponential Moving Average. The Average True Range was also implemented in combination with a 20-period EMA. The second chart shows Nvidia starting a downtrend with a sharp decline below the lower channel line.

Using the methods described above, traders and investors can identify the trend to establish a trading preference. Bullish trades are favored in an uptrend and bearish trades are favored in a downtrend. A flat trend requires a more nimble approach because prices often peak at the upper channel line and trough at the lower channel line. As with all analysis techniques, Keltner Channels should be used in conjunction with other indicators and analysis. Momentum indicators offer a good complement to the trend-following Keltner Channels. This is not to say that the price action won’t go against the newly initiated position.

Once the second candle closed below the low of the preceding red candlestick and inside of the envelopes, Ford was done. You will notice on first glance at the chart that the channel is much tighter on the Keltner Channel. I’m not as scientific as my other trader brethren are, so I’m not going to get into the details of the Keltner Channel formula, but rather will show you the inputs of the Keltner Channel.

This seems to have the same working nomenclature with CAP trading channel. I believe the concepts can be applied the same regardless of timeframe as long as there’s sufficient liquidity in the markets. So far out of the hundreds of price action mentors out there, there are like only 2 that i’ve come across who believes in verifying their results and have made them available. This means the best time to do it is when the volatility of the market is low. If the market is in a range, you can “buy low and sell high” within the boundaries of the range. You don’t buy just because the price is at the upper band of the Keltner Channels.

Don’t make this common mistake when using the Keltner Channel indicator

The direction of the moving average dictates the direction of the channel. In general, a downtrend is present when the channel moves lower, while an uptrend exists when the channel moves higher. Because standard deviation is a measure of volatility, when the markets become more volatile the bands widen while during less volatile periods, the bands contract. Many traders believe the closer the prices move to the upper band, the more overbought the market, and the closer the prices move to the lower band, the more oversold the market. I am a self-proclaimed ATR fanatic, yet I have not explored Keltner Channels. The Keltner Channel is a lagging on-chart indicator that uses a combination of exponential moving averages and the Average True Range as inputs.

A surge above the upper channel line shows extraordinary strength, while a plunge below the lower channel line shows extraordinary weakness. Such strong moves can signal the end of one trend and the beginning of another. Today we are going to discuss two important tools for identifying support and resistance on any chart – introducing price channels and bollinger bands! As a result, the volatility-based technical indicator bears many similarities to Bollinger Bands®.

If the candles start to break out above the TOP, then the move will usually continue to go UP. Breakouts from the Keltner Channel act as strong hints where the price is running off to next. In a RANGING MARKET, price usually swings back and forth between the top and bottom lines. This middle line is calculated bets pretty significant since it tends to act as a pullback level during ongoing trends. Keltner Channels show the area where a currency pair normally hangs out. Linda’s version of the Keltner Channel, which is more widely used, is quite similar to Bollinger Bands in that it also consists of three lines.

bollinger bands vs keltner channels

This particular technique has been advocated by Kerry Lovvorn of for years. is owned and operated by NERD CURIOSITY MEDIA PRIVATE LIMITED. Content shared on this website is purely for educational purposes. Trading and/or investing in financial instruments involves market risk. and its authors/contributors are not liable for any damages and/or losses caused due to trading/investment decisions made based on the information shared on this website. Readers must consider their financial circumstances, investment objectives, experience level, and risk appetite before making trading/investment decisions. Over the last several years, multiple statistical studies and research papers have been published to understand the effectiveness of both these indicators in different market environments.

Combining the Trend-Pullback and Breakout Strategies

As volatility is baked into the Keltner Channels, the indicator does an awesome job of providing insight into stocks when they are riding the trend, strongly trending higher or breaking out. As you can see, the Keltner Channel is more sensitive to the price movements in tight channels, therefore buy and sell signals could be a bit exaggerated. The morning reversal is another powerful day trading pattern, as stocks will experience sharp snap back moves.

  • In his 1960 book, How to Make Money in Commodities, Chester Keltner introduced the “Ten-Day Moving Average Trading Rule,” which is credited as the original version of Keltner Channels.
  • The information provided by, Inc. is not investment advice.
  • The breakout strategy attempts to catch more significant directional moves.
  • From these tests, it is difficult to discern any edge offered by the Keltner Channels.
  • I consider 0.40 or more to indicate significant correlation; this is a little too close for comfort.

The Bollinger bands are more sensitive to market volatility.If a trader uses the Keltner channel in a high volatility market environment, they might miss out on numerous trading signals. High level, there are two major differences between the Keltner Channels and the Bollinger Bands. These are –The outer lines of the Keltner Channel are based on the average true range of price fluctuations. Whereas, the outer lines of the Bollinger Bands Indicator are based on the standard deviation of price fluctuations. Upper LineThe upper line of the Bollinger Bands Indicatorconnects the price points that are 2 standard deviations above the simple moving average, plotted by the middle line. Using these two indicators together will provide more strength, compared with using a single indicator.

The Keltner Channels are in general more sensitive to the price action, and Bollinger Bands perform better in eliminating market noise. A trader could use the “Hide” setting at the top-left to check one without the other and compare the upper and lower limits on both before placing a trade. The price being near the lower Keltner band indicates we are trading at critical support levels. Conversely, we can open short it if we believe the price will go down further.

Bollinger Bands®

Breakouts from the Keltner Channel act as strong hints where price is running off to next. Rayner Teo is an independent trader, ex-prop trader, and founder of TradingwithRayner. Nice one i know this can work as a strategy for some people while trading. Insert the Keltner Channels and 200-period Moving Average on your charts. On hindsight, it’s easy to identify the current market condition. That’s why you need another signal to tell you the market is likely to reverse higher.

When using Keltner Channels, the default setting is usually 20 and a multiplier of 1. Also, you can change the bands style by selecting whether you want the average true range , true range , or the range. The Keltner Channel indicator is measures volatility based on the highs and lows of an instrument’s price.

Learn How To Trade In The Stock Market In 5 Steps

The most well-known volatility channel is the Bollinger Band, though the Keltner Channel Indicator is another effective type as well. Whereas the standard deviation component of Bollinger Bands gives enough of a range between the upper and lower bands to better handle significant gaps that reverse sharply and range bound markets. However, as the Bollinger Bands are calculated using standard deviations, the bands do a much better job of filtering out the noise within a range bound market. Therefore, in the snap back reversal, Bollinger Bands are more suitable as the indicator is based on standard deviations. The crazier the action, the wider the Bollinger Bands will expand, which will clearly display the breakdown if the stock starts to give it up. The outer bands are based on the standard deviation of price fluctuations.

The Channel-Cross works best when the general volatility is low – when the trend does not fluctuate back and forth a lot. When volatility increases, the accuracy of the Channel-Cross decreases because both channels will cross each other frequently. Thus, the Keltner Channel projects the true width of the price range.

Bollinger Bands vs. Keltner Channels

IBM dipped below the lower channel line three times from late May until late August. The stock did not manage to reach the upper channel line, but did get close as it reversed in the resistance zone. Bollinger Bands are more volatile than Keltner channels because their outer bands are based on standard deviation rather than the average true range. For this reason,in a high volatility market environment, for longer-term trading, Keltner Channels are LESS likely to give a false trading signal. With an exponential moving average as its foundation, Keltner Channels are a trend following indicator. As with moving averages and other trend-following indicators, Keltner Channels lag price action.

Think of the channel like an ascending or descending channel, except it automatically adjust to recent volatility and isn’t made up of straight lines. The ability to efficiently trade a diversified portfolio of strategies is one of the biggest advantages of algorithmic trading. Here we will use QuantAnalyzer’s Portfolio Master to build a portfolio consisting of high performing, uncorrelated strategies. Trading highly-correlated strategies is detrimental to your portfolio’s risk-adjusted returns.

Keltner Channels are volatility-based envelopes set above and below an exponential moving average. This indicator is similar to Bollinger Bands, which use the standard deviation to set the bands. Instead of using the standard deviation, Keltner Channels use the Average True Range to set channel distance. The channels are typically set two Average True Range values above and below the 20-day EMA. The exponential moving average dictates direction and the Average True Range sets channel width. Keltner Channels are a trend following indicator used to identify reversals with channel breakouts and channel direction.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *